Greek Yogurt Substitute

Whether you have dietary restrictions, an empty yogurt container, or simply want to experiment, this handy baking guide makes choosing the right Greek yogurt substitute easy! From sour cream and cottage cheese to non-dairy alternatives like coconut cream and mashed banana, you'll discover a wide array of substitutes for Greek yogurt tailored to suit your needs in a variety of recipes, spanning from muffins and cakes to smoothies and beyond!

Jump to:

• What is Greek yogurt exactly?
• What's the difference between Greek yogurt and yogurt?
• Considerations when replacing Greek yogurt
• What is the best Greek yogurt substitute?
• 1. Dairy Greek yogurt substitutes
• 1.1. Skyr
• 1.2. Plain yogurt
• 1.3. Sour Cream
• 1.4. Creme Fraiche
• 1.5. Cottage Cheese
• 1.6. Ricotta Cheese
• 1.7. Labneh
• 1.8. Buttermilk
• 1.9. Kefir
• 1.10. Cream Cheese
• 1.11. Whipped Feta
• 2. Non-Dairy Greek Yogurt substitutes
• 2.1. Plant based yogurt
• 2.2. Silken tofu
• 2.3. Mashed banana or pumpkin puree
• 2.4. Mashed avocado
• 2.5. Mayonnaise 
• 2.6. Coconut Cream 
• 2.7. Applesauce 
• Greek Yogurt Substitutes FAQs
• Conclusions
• More Substitute Guides
• The BEST Greek Yogurt Substitute

What is Greek yogurt exactly?

Greek yogurt is a type of yogurt that undergoes a unique straining process to remove the whey, which is the liquid remaining after milk has been curdled and strained. This process significantly reduces its water content, resulting in a thicker consistency compared to regular yogurt. It also makes it more concentrated, leading to a product that is tangier in taste and higher in protein. 

These qualities make Greek yogurt a versatile ingredient that can be used in a wide range of sweet and savory recipes. Its ability to seamlessly blend into almost any recipe while adding moisture and a distinct flavor is unparalleled. 

What's the difference between Greek yogurt and yogurt?

When comparing Greek yogurt to regular yogurt, the primary distinction lies in their texture and protein content. While also made with milk and live bacterial cultures, regular yogurt doesn't undergo the extensive straining process of Greek yogurt. Consequently, Greek yogurt has a higher protein content, lower carbohydrate levels, and a reduced amount of sugar and lactose. 

The straining process also imparts a thicker texture and a more robust, tangier flavor to Greek yogurt, distinguishing it from the milder and more fluid regular yogurt.

Considerations when replacing Greek yogurt

When replacing Greek yogurt in a recipe, you need to consider the role it plays. Is it for creaminess, tanginess, or as a binding agent? Understanding this will help you choose the most appropriate substitute that will maintain the integrity of your dish.

For example, when choosing Greek yogurt substitutes for baking, it should have a similar fat content and acidity to ensure it interacts correctly with the other ingredients like baking powder and baking soda. This interaction is crucial for achieving the desired texture and rise of your baked goods.

On the other hand, for something like a smoothie, dip, or frosting, it’s important to pick one of the Greek yogurt substitutes with a comparable texture and taste. The substitute should complement the other flavors in the recipe while maintaining the desired creamy consistency.

What is the best Greek yogurt substitute?

Choosing the best Greek yogurt substitute largely depends on the specific needs of your recipe and any dietary preferences you may have. 

For those seeking dairy-based options, sour cream, buttermilk, or even kefir can serve as excellent alternatives, each bringing a unique texture and flavor. Sour cream, for example, offers a richness and tanginess that can elevate savory dishes or baked goods. Buttermilk, with its lower fat content and distinctive tang, is particularly useful in baking, contributing to moist and fluffy textures.

Yet, if you’re looking for plant-based alternatives, vegan yogurt, and silken tofu are just two of the many viable options. Vegan yogurt offers a creamy texture and a subtly sweet flavor. Silken tofu, with its smooth and neutral profile, can be blended to mimic the creaminess of Greek yogurt without adding any additional flavor.

This baking guide will help you find the perfect substitute for yogurt in baking and also cover what can replace Greek yogurt in cooking.

1. Dairy Greek yogurt substitutes

1.1. Skyr

Skyr is a traditional Icelandic dairy product that shares many similarities with Greek yogurt. Made by fermenting skimmed milk with live bacterial cultures, it has a thick and creamy texture with a mild, slightly tangy flavor.

How to use it: 

Skyr can be substituted for Greek yogurt at a 1:1 ratio. It works well in any recipe that calls for traditional Greek yogurt! From baked goods, sauces, and dips to smoothies and my incredibly delicious mango mousse cake! 

1.2. Plain yogurt

Made from whole milk and cream, plain yogurt undergoes a fermentation process just like Greek yogurt, which makes it a great substitute in most Greek yogurt recipes. However, it’s not as thick and has a more subtle flavor.

How to use it: 

Use plain yogurt at a 1:1 ratio. It’s ideal for baking and as a base in smoothies, dressings, and marinades. For a thicker consistency, you can strain it with cheesecloth to remove some of the excess moisture.

1.3. Sour Cream

If you’re wondering, can I substitute sour cream for yogurt? Yes! Sour cream is a high-fat dairy product that has been fermented with lactic acid bacteria, which gives it a creamy texture and bold tangy flavor. For this reason, It can seamlessly replace Greek yogurt in any sweet or savory recipe.

How to use it: 

It excels as a 1:1 substitute in any recipe. In fact, you can easily use this Greek yogurt sour cream substitute ratio to make my baked cinnamon sugar donuts.

1.4. Creme Fraiche

Originating from France, creme fraiche is a cultured dairy product crafted by fermenting heavy cream with lactic acid bacteria. It has a milder and less tangy flavor compared to Greek yogurt but a more luxurious texture and higher fat content. 

How to use it: 

Creme fraiche serves as a 1:1 replacement for Greek yogurt. Its velvety texture makes it an ideal candidate for creamy dressings, rich sauces, and indulgent desserts. You can also adjust its tanginess by simply adding a touch of lemon juice or vinegar.

1.5. Cottage Cheese

Created by curdling cow's milk and then draining the whey, Cottage cheese makes an excellent Greek yogurt substitute. It offers a mild, slightly tangy taste and high-fat content. Despite its distinct texture, you can blend it into a smooth consistency, making it a versatile substitute.

How to use it: 

First, blend cottage cheese in a blender or food processor and then use it in a 1:1 ratio. It works well in pancakes, different types of cheesecake, and baked goods.

1.6. Ricotta Cheese

Ricotta cheese is a creamy, mild Italian cheese with a texture that is smoother than cottage cheese but less creamy than Greek yogurt. Traditionally made from the whey leftover from making other cheeses, ricotta cheese has a slightly sweet flavor and works well in a variety of recipes. 

How to use it: 

Ricotta cheese works as a 1:1 substitute, especially in recipes that require a mild, slightly sweet cheese flavor. It's ideal in most baked goods like muffins and cakes as well as fillings and spreads.

1.7. Labneh

Labneh, a thick and creamy Middle Eastern cheese with a mild tangy flavor, originates from straining yogurt to eliminate the excess whey. This process results in a denser and more concentrated cheese that you can thin to create a consistency similar to Greek yogurt.

How to use it: 

First, mix labneh with water or milk to achieve the right consistency, and then use it as a 1:1 substitute for Greek yogurt in baking or cooking. It’s ideal for my Greek yogurt cookies!

1.8. Buttermilk

Buttermilk, a dairy product known for its distinct tangy flavor, results from the liquid left over after churning cream into butter. You'll find it frequently added to baked goods due to it's high level of acidity that adds a pleasant tanginess and interacts well with leavening agents.

How to use it: 

Use ¾ cup of buttermilk to replace 1 cup of Greek yogurt. It works especially good in pancakes, muffins, and quick bread recipes where its tang and tenderness are desired.

1.9. Kefir

Kefir is a fermented milk drink that is thinner than Greek yogurt but offers similar probiotic benefits. Often described as a cross between yogurt and buttermilk, its tangy taste makes it a good substitute even though it differs in thickness.

How to use it: 

To substitute kefir for Greek yogurt, use ¾ cup of kefir for every 1 cup of Greek yogurt. It is suitable in recipes that benefit from a probiotic-rich, tangy liquid, such as baked goods. It also makes a fantastic Greek yogurt substitute for salad dressing.

1.10. Cream Cheese

Produced by blending cream and milk with lactic acid, cream cheese has a mild, slightly sweet flavor, coupled with a hint of tanginess. Yet, despite its dense texture, you can easily thin it out to match the consistency of Greek yogurt.

How to use it: 

To use cream cheese as a substitute, mix it with lemon juice or water until it reaches the right consistency that is more similar to Greek yogurt. Then use it in a 1:1 ratio for spreads, dips, frostings, and baked dessert recipes.

1.11. Whipped Feta

Crafted by blending feta cheese with cream or milk, creamy whipped feta provides a rich, salty flavor, making it an excellent choice for savory recipes.

How to use it: 

Blend feta with cream or milk until smooth and then use in a 1:1 ratio. Whipped feta is an ideal choice for savory baked goods, spreads, and dips.

2. Non-Dairy Greek Yogurt substitutes

2.1. Plant based yogurt

Crafted from various dairy free milks like almond, soy, or coconut, plant-based yogurt works as a Greek yogurt substitute. The different varieties vary in taste and thickness, providing a range of options for those who follow a non-dairy or vegan diet. 

How to use it:

Use a ratio of ¾ cup of plant-based yogurt for every 1 cup your recipe calls for. This Greek yogurt substitute vegan option will work in any recipe. Just make sure to use unsweetened varieties unless you want added flavor and sweetness. 

2.2. Silken tofu

Silken tofu is an excellent dairy-free substitute due to its neutral taste and adaptability. Made from soybeans, it has a silky texture that when blended with lemon juice, yields a creamy consistency with a tangy flavor. 

How to use it:

Blend silken tofu until smooth with a splash of lemon juice for a touch of acidity. The ratio typically used is ¾ cup of silken tofu for every 1 cup of Greek yogurt. This substitute is particularly suitable for recipes that call for a creamy, neutral base, such as baked goods or smoothies.

2.3. Mashed banana or pumpkin puree

Both of these Greek yogurt substitutes are dairy-free and offer natural sweetness. Mashed bananas, the sweeter of the two, have a thick and creamy texture. While pumpkin puree provides a velvety, mildly sweet base that is ideal for sweet and savory recipes. You can even make pumpkin puree from scratch. 

How to use it:

Use a 1:1 ratio of mashed banana or pumpkin puree. These two alternatives work best in smoothies, cakes, pancakes, and muffin recipes. You may also want to consider adjusting the sugar content in your recipe as bananas and pumpkins add their own natural sweetness to the mix.

2.4. Mashed avocado

Mashed avocado is an excellent rich and creamy plant-based substitute for Greek yogurt. While it differs in taste and texture, its healthy fat content and rich, buttery profile make it an appealing choice.

How to use it:

Substitute mashed avocado at a 1:1 ratio. This alternative works exceptionally well in recipes where its creamy texture and mild, nutty flavor can enhance both the consistency and taste.

2.5. Mayonnaise 

Can mayo be substituted for Greek yogurt? Absolutely! Mayonnaise can serve as a surprisingly effective alternative, especially when you want a creamy and indulgent texture. While it differs significantly in flavor and composition, its ability to enrich recipes with its high-fat content and tanginess makes it an appealing option.

How to use it:

Use a 1:1 ratio in your recipes but keep in mind that it has higher fat content which can significantly alter the outcome of baked goods. Mayo is an ideal Greek yogurt substitute for baking and savory dishes when you want to add more richness and moisture. 

2.6. Coconut Cream 

Derived from the flesh of mature coconuts, coconut cream is a popular vegan alternative.  Although it varies in taste, its creamy consistency and tropical flavor make it a delicious choice. 

How to use it:

Use a 1:1 ratio, mixing it with lemon juice or vinegar to add a touch of sourness if desired. Coconut cream is especially suitable for dishes where a hint of coconut flavor enhances the overall taste. 

2.7. Applesauce 

Applesauce serves as an excellent Greek yogurt substitute when you want a touch of natural sweetness and moisture. While it differs from Greek yogurt in texture and flavor, its ability to create a moist and tender texture in baked goods while reducing fat content makes it a valuable alternative.

How to use it:

Use a 1:1 ratio. Applesauce works particularly well in apple desserts like cakes, muffins, and pancakes, where it can enhance both the taste and texture. This spiced apple cake is a great example.

Greek Yogurt Substitutes FAQs

Conclusions

So, what can you use in place of Greek yogurt in a recipe? There's no single "best" alternative. Each substitute brings its own unique qualities and flavors to the table.

Choosing the perfect substitute for Greek yogurt depends on your specific needs and preferences. This comprehensive baking guide not only presents you with a myriad of options, ranging from dairy-based alternatives like Skyr and sour cream to innovative plant-based choices like silken tofu and mashed banana, but it also helps you to understand the different characteristics and roles of each alternative. 

Whether you need a Greek yogurt substitute that closely mimics the texture and tanginess or one that introduces a new dimension of flavor to your recipes, this baking guide has you covered!

More Substitute Guides