Working in a restaurant often means dealing with the unexpected. From unclear orders to puzzling requests, food service professionals accumulate stories that can make them laugh or shake their heads long after the moment has passed. Some requests remain baffling even years later.
The question
In a recent Reddit post, it was asked, "Hey chefs, just for fun, what is the stupidest request you’ve had from a customer?" The poster went on to say that, even though it's been 13 years, he still remembers the oddest request from a customer, revolving around an egg, a sandwich, and a misunderstanding.
The customer asked for “toast bacon egg (hide the egg)”. He was genuinely confused, and in the end, he sent out the egg under the toast. Turns out they wanted the egg “flipped” and were furious.
He wasn't alone with wild stories and tales. Over 1,000 comments were added to the thread, revealing even more crazy stories from industry insiders.
The reactions
Everyone had their own rare story, and almost all of them delivered laughs and disbelief.
One person said, "Back when I worked at a ramen shop, this woman got all furious because we didn't have chicken tenders and fries for her kid."
It just sounds absurd. Yes, kids can be super picky, but what did the customer expect from a ramen shop? Burgers and fries?
Another person said, "Two days ago someone sent back the butter because they wanted the gluten free version, due to their gluten allergy."
Interesting. Maybe this is because some people just want others to know that they have an allergy because they're super anxious that something is going to cross-contaminate their food?
Then there was this order. "Loaded baked potato, no potato. Just a pile of cheese, butter, sour cream, bacon, and chive."
That's one way to make it your own.
Another request was, "Can you pick the clams out of my chowder?"
This is super picky, and also super unlikely. Restaurants typically don't make things from scratch; if it's something like soup of the day, if this person doesn't want clams in their chowder, they're going to have to pick them out themselves.
One person wrote, "We had a woman walk in once who immediately started looking at the ceiling. When asked how we could help her she said she would come back when we got higher efficiency lightbulbs then left."
This is a new one. This is a bit odd, but who knows? There could have been something about the place that she didn't care for, and she focused on the lighting as her excuse. Or she might really be sensitive to different types of lighting.
Then there was this. "When I was working on the line I remember getting a request for kale salad, no kale."
So, a plate of just other added veggies? Or would they want the kale to be substituted with iceberg lettuce?
This person wowed quite a few people. "When I worked in a country club, I had one regular who would always ask for the crusts to be cut off his sandwich and sent out on a side plate so he could make sure I wasn't ripping him off by cutting too much off."
This is so wild it's almost hard to believe.
One person said, "Customer was so cheap asked for a bowl of lemons, and water for hot tea, but no tea bag. Sat there and proceeded to make their own lemonade with all the sugar packets.....just to save 1.39."
Everyone has a budget, and this person obviously didn't want to spend that extra money to have lemonade made for them. They literally took lemons and made their own lemonade.
Some people have no clue. "When I worked at a high end joint in NYC, I had a dirty martini returned because it tasted like olives."
That's literally the point and taste of a dirty martini.
This comment said, "Cinnamon roll covered in gravy instead of chocolate caramel sauce. He was drunk, but he ate it."
Sounds like he committed and then stuck with it. Kudos to him for not making a scene over what was likely a mistake due to his own alcohol intake.
How to react to crazy requests from customers
In the service industry, strange requests come with the territory. Some are harmless, and others are so confusing that they leave staff second-guessing reality. How you respond in those moments can shape the customer’s experience and even the mood of the shift.
The first step is staying calm, even when the request sounds unreasonable. Most people are not trying to cause trouble. They may be confused or simply unaware of how a dish is prepared. Responding with patience keeps the situation from escalating and buys you time to figure out what they actually want.
Clarifying is often more important than agreeing. Asking simple follow-up questions can prevent misunderstandings that lead to complaints or remakes. If something is not possible, it helps to explain why in plain language rather than shutting the request down abruptly.
There is also value in knowing when to set boundaries. Not every request is safe or fair to the kitchen. The goal is not to say yes to everything, but to handle unusual requests with professionalism and respect.
Leave a Reply